2023 USL League Two First Team Roster
| Postion | Name | Nationality | Hometown | College/Club | |
| 1 | GK | Sebastian Doppelhofer | Austria | Liebmannweg, Austria | Lewis Univ. (IL) |
| 2 | D | Galen Flynn | USA | West Hartford, CT | St. Louis Univ. |
| 3 | D | Shaun Russell | USA | Chesapeake, VA | Saint Francis (PA) |
| 4 | D | Dylan Evande | USA | Hackensack, NJ | Kean Univ. |
| 5 | D | Jan Riecke | Germany | Berlin, Germany | Harvard |
| 6 | M | Tyrese Small | Jamaica | Kingston, Jamaica | Wilmington Univ. |
| 7 | F | Colin Veltri | USA | Mays Landing, NJ | St. John's |
| 8 | M | Sander Roed | Norway | Tranby, Norway | Louisville |
| 9 | F | Jack Sarkos | USA | Margate City, NJ | UCLA |
| 10 | F | Alessandro Arlotti | Italy | San Remo, Italy | Harvard |
| 11 | F | Jamie Davis | England | Cheshire, England | Univ. of New Hampshire / St. Peter's |
| 12 | D | Joao de Oliveira | Brazil | Santa Catarina, Brazil | Bethel College |
| 13 | D | Shane Clancy | USA | Sicklerville, NJ | Jacksonville Univ. |
| 14 | D | Raimondo Partito | USA | Philadelphia, PA | Rutgers-Camden |
| 15 | M | Nico Rubio | USA | Egg Harbor Township, NJ | Seton Hall |
| 16 | D | Marco Torino | Italy | Westchester, NY | St. Peter's Univ. |
| 17 | F | Danny Russo | USA | Jackson, NJ | Notre Dame |
| 18 | F | Ryan Peterson | USA | Budd Lake, NJ | NC State / Rutgers |
| 19 | M | Nick Pariano | USA | Philadelphia, PA | Duke |
| 20 | F | Andrew Kitch | USA | Medford, NJ | North Carolina |
| 21 | D | Simbarashe Mazarura | Zimbabwe | Harare, Zimbabwe | Camden County College |
| 22 | M | Maruki Kawahara | Japan | Tochigi, Japan | Nebraska-Omaha |
| 23 | D | Tapiwa Machingauta | Zimbabwe | Marondera, Zimbabwe | Bradley |
| 33 | GK | Owen Moore | USA | Pilesgrove, NJ | Liberty |
| 66 | GK | Stefano Camerlengo | Italy | Pescara, Italy | Missouri-Kansas City |
| 99 | GK | Brady Hochman | USA | Clarksboro, NJ | Rosemont College / Millersville Univ. |
| F | Ryan Becher | USA | Hummelstown, PA | UCLA | |
| M | Leonardo D'Ambrosio | Italy | Turin, Italy | College of Charleston | |
| D | Brad Dildy | USA | San Antonio, TX | Univ. of Charlotte | |
| F | Kyle Galloway | USA | Manahawkin, NJ | Marist College / Rutgers | |
| D | Josh Jones | USA | Hatfield, PA | Louisville | |
| D | Yousif Kowa | USA | Buffalo, NY | Buffalo State | |
| D | Bryce Meredith | USA | Raleigh, NC | Memphis | |
| M | Andre "Dede" Sabino | Brazil | Rondonopolis, Brazil | Bethel College | |
| GK | Felix Schafer | Germany | Berlin, Germany | Santa Clara | |
| F | Daniele Verdirosi | Italy | Rome, Italy | Indian Hills |
